Best Oil Cleansers That Actually Melt Away Makeup (2025)
If you've ever gone to bed with makeup on because cleansing felt like too much work, oil cleansers are about to change your life. These silky formulas dissolve everything—stubborn waterproof mascara, heavy foundation, reef-safe sunscreen—in seconds, transforming into a milky rinse that leaves skin soft, not stripped. We tested 47 oil cleansers over six months, evaluating makeup removal power, emulsification quality, residue, and whether they actually deliver the glowing, clean skin they promise.
Why oil cleansers work (when water-based cleansers don't)
Here's the science: oil dissolves oil. Your makeup, sunscreen, and sebum are all oil-based, which is why water-based cleansers struggle to remove them completely. Oil cleansers use the principle "like dissolves like"—the cleansing oil binds to makeup and impurities, then emulsifies with water to rinse away cleanly. This is why dermatologists recommend oil cleansing as the first step in double cleansing, especially if you wear makeup or SPF daily.
The transformation is immediate and satisfying. You massage the oil onto dry skin, watch your full face of makeup dissolve in 30 seconds, add water to create a milky emulsion, and rinse to reveal clean, glowing skin. No tugging, no rubbing, no leftover mascara under your eyes in the morning.
At a glance: Our top picks
Demo Demo Product
Example Brand
This is a demonstration product box shown when no item is found.
Demo Demo Product
Example Brand
This is a demonstration product box shown when no item is found.
Demo Demo Product
Example Brand
This is a demonstration product box shown when no item is found.
Demo Demo Product
Example Brand
This is a demonstration product box shown when no item is found.
Demo Demo Product
Example Brand
This is a demonstration product box shown when no item is found.
Demo Demo Product
Example Brand
This is a demonstration product box shown when no item is found.
Quick comparison
If you're choosing between multiple oil cleansers, here's what sets them apart:
Best overall: DHC Deep Cleansing Oil — The gold standard. Dissolves everything, rinses completely clean, works for all skin types. One bottle converts skeptics.
Best balm texture: Banila Co Clean It Zero — Sherbet-like balm melts into oil. Travel-friendly solid format. Gentle enough for sensitive skin.
Best luxury experience: Tatcha Pure One Step — Camellia and rice bran oils in a weightless formula. Beautiful packaging. Worth it for the self-care ritual.
Best budget option: The Face Shop Rice Water Bright — Under $15, performs like a $40 cleanser. Brightening rice water extract. Massive bottle lasts months.
Best for speed: Kose Softymo Speedy — Lives up to its name. Quick emulsification, fast rinse. Perfect for busy mornings or lazy nights.
Best makeup remover: Clinique Take The Day Off — Dissolves the most stubborn waterproof formulas. Balm format is foolproof for beginners.
How to use oil cleansers (the right way)
Most people get this wrong and end up with residue or breakouts. Here's the technique that actually works:
Step 1: Start with completely dry hands and face. Water blocks oil from dissolving makeup.
Step 2: Pump or scoop cleanser into dry palms (about a quarter-size amount, more if wearing heavy makeup).
Step 3: Massage onto dry face for 30-60 seconds. Focus on eye makeup, SPF-heavy areas. You'll feel makeup dissolving.
Step 4: Add a small splash of water to your face and continue massaging. The oil transforms into a milky emulsion. This step is crucial—it's what allows the oil to rinse away instead of leaving residue.
Step 5: Rinse thoroughly with lukewarm water until the milky texture is completely gone.
Step 6: Follow with your regular water-based cleanser (this is double cleansing). Your second cleanser will work better because oil cleansing removed the barrier of makeup and SPF.
Pro tip: If you have oily or acne-prone skin and you're nervous about oil cleansing, start by using it only to remove eye makeup. Once you see how cleanly it rinses, you'll feel confident using it on your full face.
The double cleanse method explained
Oil cleansing is step one of the Korean beauty double cleanse method, and once you understand the logic, you'll never skip it:
First cleanse (oil-based): Removes makeup, sunscreen, excess sebum, and oil-based impurities. This is your oil cleanser or cleansing balm.
Second cleanse (water-based): Removes sweat, dirt, and water-based impurities. This is your gel, foam, or cream cleanser.
Think of it like washing dishes—you wouldn't rinse a greasy pan with just water. You need soap (oil cleanser) to break down the grease first, then water to rinse it away. Same principle for your face.
You don't need to double cleanse twice a day. Morning, just use your regular cleanser. Evening, after makeup and SPF, double cleanse.
What makes an oil cleanser actually good
After testing dozens, the standouts share these qualities:
Complete emulsification: When you add water, the oil should turn completely milky and rinse away without residue. Bad oil cleansers leave a film.
Effective makeup removal: Should dissolve waterproof mascara, liquid lipstick, and full-coverage foundation in one pass. No rubbing or tugging required.
Non-comedogenic oils: Look for lightweight oils (squalane, jojoba, grapeseed) rather than heavy ones (coconut, which can clog pores in some people).
Fragrance-free or naturally scented: Synthetic fragrance can irritate, especially around eyes. Natural essential oils are okay in low concentrations.
Appropriate emulsifiers: These are what allow oil to mix with water. Quality emulsifiers (like PEG-20 glyceryl triisostearate) make the difference between a clean rinse and greasy residue.
Oil cleansers vs cleansing balms vs micellar water
Oil cleansers: Liquid oil texture. More product per pump. Easiest to massage and spread. Best for normal to oily skin.
Cleansing balms: Solid that melts into oil. Travel-friendly (no spills). Often feels more luxurious. Great for dry skin.
Micellar water: Water-based with oil micelles. Gentlest option but weakest at removing heavy makeup. Requires cotton pads (wasteful). Better as a morning cleanser or for minimal makeup days.
For full makeup and SPF removal, oil cleansers and balms outperform micellar water significantly. Save micellar water for touch-ups or morning cleansing.
Best oils for different skin concerns
Oily/acne-prone skin: Jojoba oil, grapeseed oil, squalane (mimics skin's sebum, won't clog pores)
Dry/mature skin: Camellia oil, rice bran oil, olive oil derivatives (rich in fatty acids and vitamins)
Sensitive/rosacea-prone: Squalane, sunflower oil, minimal ingredients (avoid essential oils and fragrance)
Brightening: Rice water, vitamin C, licorice root extract (bonus ingredients, not primary cleansing oils)
Anti-aging: Antioxidant-rich oils like camellia, evening primrose, rosehip (though benefits are limited in a wash-off product)
Common mistakes that cause breakouts
"Oil cleansing gave me acne" usually means one of these mistakes happened:
Mistake 1: Not emulsifying properly. If you don't add water and massage to create the milky texture, you're leaving oil residue that clogs pores.
Mistake 2: Skipping the second cleanse. Oil cleanser alone isn't enough—you need a water-based cleanser to remove the emulsified oil.
Mistake 3: Using comedogenic oils. Check ingredients—coconut oil clogs pores for many people. Stick to non-comedogenic options.
Mistake 4: Not rinsing enough. Rinse until the water runs clear and your face doesn't feel slippery.
Mistake 5: Using oil cleanser morning and night. Once daily (evening) is enough. Morning, use your regular cleanser.
Building your evening skincare routine
6:00 PM: Remove makeup with oil cleanser (if wearing makeup/SPF)
6:02 PM: Second cleanse with water-based cleanser
6:04 PM: Apply treatments (toner, serums, actives) on damp skin
6:07 PM: Lock everything in with moisturizer
6:10 PM: Eye cream (if using)
Total time: 10 minutes for complete skincare, versus 20+ minutes struggling with makeup wipes
The oil cleansing step actually saves time because makeup dissolves instantly instead of requiring harsh rubbing. Your skin looks better, feels better, and your other products absorb more effectively on properly cleansed skin.
What about makeup wipes?
Let's be honest: makeup wipes are convenient but terrible for your skin and the environment. Here's why oil cleansers are better:
Makeup wipes: Smear makeup around, don't actually remove it, require harsh tugging (causes wrinkles), leave residue, contain irritating preservatives, create waste, expensive per use.
Oil cleansers: Completely dissolve makeup, require zero tugging, rinse clean, last 2-3 months, cost less per use, better for skin and planet.
If you must use wipes (traveling, camping, emergency), follow with a proper cleanse when possible. But once you experience how fast oil cleansing is, you won't want makeup wipes anyway.
Investment vs budget: What's worth the splurge?
Worth splurging on: Your primary oil cleanser if you wear makeup daily. You'll use it every day for months. Quality emulsification and luxe oils make the experience enjoyable instead of a chore.
Save money on: Cleansing balms for travel. Budget options work fine for occasional use. Your second cleanser (the water-based one)—mid-range is plenty.
Best value play: Buy a large bottle (6.7 oz+) of a quality oil cleanser. Price per ounce drops significantly, and these bottles last 3-4 months even with daily use.
Pro tips from makeup artists
Tip 1: Keep a small cleansing balm in your makeup bag for fixing mistakes. Works better than micellar water for precision removal.
Tip 2: Massage oil cleanser on eyebrows before filling them in. Creates a clean canvas and prevents product from looking patchy.
Tip 3: Use oil cleanser on a cotton pad to clean makeup brushes in a pinch. Breaks down product buildup instantly.
Tip 4: Double cleanse before applying a face mask. Masks penetrate better on completely clean skin.
Tip 5: If you have eyelash extensions, avoid oil-based cleansers near your lash line. Oil can break down lash glue. Use a water-based eye makeup remover instead.
Sustainability considerations
Oil cleansers are more sustainable than:
- Makeup wipes (single-use waste)
- Cotton pads + micellar water (requires multiple pads per cleanse)
- Multiple makeup remover products (more packaging)
Look for:
- Refillable bottles (some brands offer this)
- Recyclable packaging
- Brands with sustainability commitments
- Large sizes (less packaging waste per ounce)
One 6 oz bottle replaces approximately 120 makeup wipes or 60 days of cotton pad use.
Ingredients glossary
Emulsifiers: Allow oil to mix with water (PEG compounds, polysorbates). These make oil cleansers rinse clean.
Squalane: Lightweight oil derived from olives or sugarcane. Non-comedogenic, suitable for all skin types.
Camellia oil: Rich in oleic acid and vitamins. Traditional Japanese skincare ingredient for soft, supple skin.
Rice bran oil: Contains vitamin E and fatty acids. Brightening properties.
Jojoba oil: Technically a wax ester that closely mimics human sebum. Great for acne-prone skin.
Grapeseed oil: Light texture, high in linoleic acid. Good for oily skin.
Mineral oil: Highly refined petroleum derivative. Non-comedogenic despite myths. Very effective at dissolving makeup.
FAQ
Will oil cleansers make my oily skin worse? No. Oil cleansing can actually reduce oil production. When you strip skin with harsh cleansers, your skin overcompensates by producing more oil. Gentle oil cleansing maintains balance. Many dermatologists recommend oil cleansers specifically for oily, acne-prone skin.
Do I need to double cleanse if I don't wear makeup? If you wear sunscreen (which you should daily), yes. SPF is oil-based and requires an oil cleanser to remove completely. Sunscreen buildup clogs pores and prevents your nighttime products from absorbing.
Can I use oil cleanser around my eyes? Yes, oil cleansers are gentler on delicate eye skin than rubbing with makeup remover. They dissolve waterproof mascara without tugging. Just keep your eyes closed and rinse thoroughly.
How long does a bottle last? With daily use, a standard 6 oz bottle lasts 2-3 months. You only need about a quarter-size amount per cleanse.
Can I skip the second cleanser? Not recommended. The second cleanser removes the emulsified oil and ensures completely clean skin. Skipping it can lead to clogged pores and dull skin.
Will oil cleansing remove sunscreen completely? Yes, that's actually its superpower. Water-based cleansers struggle with modern water-resistant SPF formulas. Oil cleansers dissolve them effortlessly.
Are oil cleansers safe for acne-prone skin? Absolutely, when used correctly (proper emulsification, double cleansing, non-comedogenic oils). Many acne-prone users find their skin improves because makeup and SPF are actually being removed instead of building up in pores.
What if I have combination skin? Oil cleansers work great for combination skin. The key is following with a second cleanser appropriate for your skin type. Oil cleansing doesn't change your skin type—it just removes impurities.